目录

2.4. 游戏行动失误~再调度失误 | 返回IPG目录 | 2.6. 游戏行动失误~未维护游戏状态

2.5 Game Rule Violation 违反游戏规则

Penalty 处罚

Warning 警告

DEFINITION 定义

This infraction covers the majority of game situations in which a player makes an error or fails to follow a game procedure correctly. It handles violations of the Comprehensive Rules that are not covered by the other Game Play Errors.
此违规涵盖了大多数关于牌手发生失误,或是没有正确的执行游戏程序而造成的游戏状况。这也用来处理违反完整规则、且未包含在其他游戏行动失误中的违规。

EXAMPLES 范例

A. A player casts Wrath of God for 3W (actual cost 2WW).
A. 牌手支付{三}{白}来施放神之愤怒/Wrath of God(正确费用为{二}{白}{白})。
B. A player does not attack with a creature that must attack each turn.
B. 牌手没有让每回合都必须攻击的生物来进行攻击。
C. A player fails to put a creature with lethal damage into a graveyard and it is not noticed until several turns later.
C. 牌手没有将受到致命伤害的生物放进坟墓场,且在数个回合之后才发现。
D. A Phyrexian Revoker is on the battlefield that should have had a card named for it.
D. 非瑞克西亚断念妖/Phyrexian Revoker 在战场上,当初应为其说一张牌名时却没有说。
E. A player casts Brainstorm and forgets to put two cards back on top of their library.
E. 牌手施放脑力激荡/Brainstorm,却忘记将两张牌放回牌库顶。

PHILOSOPHY 原则

While Game Rule Violations can be attributed to one player, they usually occur publicly and both players are expected to be mindful of what is happening in the game. It is tempting to try and “fix” these errors, but it is important that they be handled consistently, regardless of their impact on the game.
虽然违反游戏规则通常是归咎于其中一位牌手,但此类情况通常是公开地发生,且双方牌手都应留意游戏中所发生的事情。处理者应尝试去“修复”这些失误,但很重要的是:不论这些失误对游戏有多少影响,处理方式都必须一致。

ADDITIONAL REMEDY 进一步的修正

First, consider a simple backup (see section 1.4).
首先,考虑是否简单倒回(参见1.4章节)。

If a simple backup is not sufficient and the infraction falls into one or more of the following categories, and only into those categories, perform the appropriate partial fix:
如果简单倒回不足以完全修正,且违规属于下列某种情形或同属多种情形(但不得超出各情形规定之内容),则进行部分修正:

• If a player forgot to untap one or more permanents at the start of their turn and it is still the same turn, untap them.
• 如果牌手在自己回合开始时忘记重置一个或数个永久物,并且当前依然是同一个回合,则重置它们。
• If a player made an illegal choice (including no choice where required) for a static ability generating a continuous effect still on the battlefield, that player makes a legal choice.
• 如果某牌手为某个在战场上之静止式异能产生的持续性效应作出的选择不合法(包括在需要作选择时未如此作),则该牌手重新作出一个符合游戏规则的选择。
• If a player failed to draw cards, discard cards, or return cards from their hand to another zone, that player does so.
• 如果某牌手未能抓牌、弃牌或忘记将牌从手上移至其他区域,则该牌手如此作。
• If an object is not in the correct zone, the exact object is still known to all players, and it can be moved with only minor disruption to the current state of the game, put the object in the correct zone. This only applies if the object being in the wrong zone is the Game Rule Violation, and not if it is the consequence of a different error.
• 如果一个物件处于错误的区域中,且该物件依然为所有牌手所知悉、移动此物件仅会对游戏当前状态造成轻微影响,则将该物件放入正确区域。此修正仅适用于,当“违反游戏规则”的问题本身,是由于有物件处于错误的区域中而产生的,而非因其他错误导致此类结果的情况。
• If damage assignment order has not been declared, the appropriate player chooses that order.
• 如果未宣告伤害分配次序,对应牌手决定此顺序。

For each of these fixes, a simple backup may be performed beforehand if it makes applying the fix smoother. Triggered abilities are generated from these partial fixes only if they would have occurred had the action been taken at the correct time.
对于以上各修正而言,如果能让修正更平滑,可以在此之前进行一次简易倒回。对于在部分修正中产生的触发式异能,只有在这些动作在正确的时间进行也会触发的情况下,才会在这些部分修正中产生。

Otherwise, a full backup may be considered or the game state may be left as is.
若属于其他情况,则可以考虑进行完整倒回,或保留当前游戏状态不做修正。

If the game has proceeded past a point where an opponent could reasonably be expected to notice the error, the opponent has also committed an infraction. In most cases, the infraction is Game Play Error — Failure to Maintain Game State. However, if the judge believes that both players were responsible for the Game Rule Violation, such as due to the opponent controlling the continuous effect modifying the rules of the game that led to the Game Rule Violation or a player taking action based on another player’s instruction, they have instead committed a Game Play Error — Game Rule Violation. For example, if a player casts Path to Exile on an opponent’s creature and the opponent puts the creature into the graveyard, once the game has continued both players will have committed a Game Rule Violation.
如果对手没能在预期其能注意到失误的合理时间点前指出游戏行动失误,则对手也犯下违规。大多数情况下是“游戏行动失误~未维护游戏状态”。然而如果裁判认为双方牌手在本次违反游戏规则的过程中均有责任,例如是由于对手操控的改变游戏规则的持续性效应导致的,或是某位牌手根据另一位牌手的指示执行行动,则对手也犯下了“游戏行动失误~违反游戏规则”违规。例如,如果牌手向对手的生物施放流放之径/Path to Exile,且该对手将此生物放进坟墓场,一旦游戏继续进行则双方牌手均犯下“游戏行动失误~违反游戏规则”违规。